ISSN 2359-7593



Cautare Articole



Acasa > Orizont > Opinii >  

Autor: Ion Cârstoiu         Ediţia nr. 2931 din 09 ianuarie 2019        Toate Articolele Autorului

Distribuie!       Aboneaza-te!
by Ion Carstoiu 
Unfortunately, the etymon for''fish'' in world languages remains enigmatic. What's behind the word with the sense''fish''? It is not known. Do not laugh but a relationship with the ''sun'' is possible: 1)Hae in Araona(Bolivia)=hae''sun''in Korean. 2)Hare in Umotina(Brazil)=hare''sun''in Orokolo(PNG). 3)Il''fish'' in Dawera-Daweloor(Indonesia)=il''sun'' in Korean. 4)Kala''fish'' in Finnish=kala''the sun'' in Hawaiian. 5)Kanga in Kuikuro(Braz.)=kanga''sun'' in Koyo(Congo). 6)Kol in E.Mari=kol''sun'' in Scythian. 7)La in Ama(N.Guinea)=la''sun'' in Hawaiian. 8)Me in Kwakala(Canada)=me''sun'' in Yokuts. 9)In Tamil min=min''sun'' in Kansa. 10)Moi in Talysh(Iran)=moi''sun'' in Lingala(D.R.Congo). 11)Nima in Bribri(Costa Rica)=nima((nyima) in Tibetan.Now with small changes. 12)Pula(pola) in Chuvash~Apolo sun-god. 13)Palik in Khakas cf.Palk,Korean sun-god. 14)In Turkish balik,unkn.origin,,but'' page does not exist''.:b is variant of p,see also Bel,Celtic sun-god, beli''sun'' in Assamese etc. 15)Gipsy word for ''fish'' is masho cf.mash''sun'' in Nubian(Sudan). 16)Dag in Hebrew cf.daga''sun'' in Circassian. 17)Kinu in Angor(P.N.G.)~kin in Turkic and Maya. 18)Laks in Tocharian cf.lak''sun'' in Apakapa(Texas). 19)Namas in Abenaki~ nam''sun'' in Dumi(Nepal). 20)Be in Balinese''sun'' in Otoe. 21-22)Kana in Apalai(Braz.)but kan''sun'' in Ninatic(Connecticut).See also ikan in Ilokano. 23)Hoga in Assiniboine cf.khaga''sun'' in Sanskrit. 24)Na in Limbu(Nepal) from rana''sun'' in Hausa? 25)Rami in Egyptian~Ra,sun-god. 26)Ho in Kansa cf.(hol)''fish'' in Hungarian,see Finn.kala=kala''the sun'' in Hawaiian,kol''sun'' in Scythian. 27)Kapa in Scythian,kaef in Ossetian,kifi in Hausa,kupa,cep in Ainu,pa in Lao ~Khepri,*Khapri,sun-god in Anc.Egypt(h is aspiration and is eliminated). 28)Modern Greek for ''fish'' is psari which is comparable with pisar''sun'' in Nehan(PNG). 29)Pira in Tupinamba can be the final of Khepri with metathesis.or pur,pir''fire'' in Greek and Korean.(fire from sun). 30).Guya in Gamilarray~gui''sun''in Niger-Congo. 31)Ek in Marshallese cf.eke''sun'' in Onge(Andaman,India). 32)Olo in Negidal, ollo in Evenki~Apolo,Apollo? 33)Itonama (Bolivia) word for ''fish'' is opi,but op means''sun'' in Yawelmani(California). 
Wiktionary about fish:''From M.Engl.fisch,from fisc''fish'', from P.Germ.*fiskaz, from PIE*peysk-..(compare Latin piscis,Irish iasc)''..I propose instead of PIE*peysk- the name pis''sun'' in Goemai(Nigeria).+suff.-k-.=pisk. 
Latvian zivs, zuve: “Latvian zivs, dialectal zuvs, zuve, from Proto-Baltic *žuwis, from Proto-Indo-European *dʰǵʰu- (“fish”). Cognates include Lithuanian žuvìs (“fish”), Old Prussian suckis (zukis, “fish”), Ancient Greek ἰχθύς (ikhthús), Old Armenian ձուկն (jukn). 
Karulis doesn't accept the resolution of the thorn cluster and so instead sets up *ǵʰeu-wi-s, *ǵʰu-wi-s from a putative Proto-Indo-European *ǵʰew- (“fish”), comparing *ǵʰeu- (“to pour”) or *ǵʰēu-, *ǵʰəu- (“to gape”). “ 
Wiktionary Proto-Slavic/ryba: ” Of uncertain origin. 
The central Indo-European word for "fish" *dʰǵʰu- (“fish”) (yielding Ancient Greek ἰχθύς (ikhthús), Lithuanian žuvìs, Old Armenian ձուկն (jukn)) would have given Proto-Slavic v-stem **zy (genitive **zъve, accusative **zъvь), and was, as the theory goes, avoided by fishermen due to taboo, or because it would've sounded too similar to the verb *zъvati (“to call”). 
Some of the proposed etymologies include: 
• From Early Proto-Slavic *rų̄bā, which is then comparable to *rębъ (“speckled, motley, variegated”), with fish scales being the semantic connection. For a similar development compare *pьstry (“salmonid fish”), originally "the colorful/variegated one" < *pьstrъ (“variegated”). 
• From the Early Proto-Slavic root *ūr- (“water, swamp, pond”) which is attested in Baltic languages, with a rare metathesis and the suffix *-ba for forming abstract nouns.” 
S. Paliga, Cas e s t u d y :r yb a 
“Slav ic ryba has been analyzed from various perspectives and various origins have been sug- 
gested. Unfortunately, the etymon remains enigmatic. The various associations 
with other roots are mainly unconvincing. Is there possible to suggest a more 
convincing solution? Are there the ‘more convincing’ candidates for a possible 
relationship, allowing to reconstruct the initial meaning of the root *RaB-, 
*RoB-, *RuB-? … e ve n i f sharing the same root, are obviously not related, they are simple homonyms as 
a result of hazard, not an initial etymological relationship. This is, for example, 
the series represented by Latin rubius ‘red’, which cannot be related to ryba, and 
vice-versa. Nor can river-name Rubicon be related to ryba, unless we admit that 
root rub- is not connected to the semantic sphere ‘red’, as currently accepted. 
But the origin of Rubicon is not of primary interest here; it may be considered 
some time later, though. Latin had another root rob- with the meaning ‘oak’ and 
‘force’ – robur. This often happens in the etymological analysis, therefore it is 
safe to reject a possible initial relationship with these Latin forms. 
But what the initial meaning may have been? To what semantical sphere 
was a fish connected to? Definitely not to color, as fish may have various colors. 
To form? This seems most probable, especially if we have a look at how most 
fish look like: they have curvilinear forms. This is what I postulated several 
years ago, upon the first attempt to try possible related forms to Slavic ryba. 
Archaic languages did contain, in fact words related to simple data, nouns 
and adjectives, and probably little abstract meanings. Therefore, as a starting 
point, I assumed that archaic meaning of the Pre-IE root *RaB-, *RoB-, *Rub-must have been related to an obvious depictive feature, frequently encoun- 
tered when attempting to reconstruct the archaic meanings of prehistoric 
roots. The association of various fish with the curvilinear forms is obvious, 
e.g. these examples of Czech heraldry (after Zenger 1978: 62 and 151). 
Starting from this observation, we may postulate 
that the initial meaning of the Pre-IE root *R-B- must 
have been ‘curved, rotund; curvilinear; round, roun- 
ded; wheel.’ If we admit this reconstruction, the next 
step would be to identify other possibly related forms.” 
Did you see etymologies of Slavic*ryba and Latvian zivs, zuve? In my opinion Slavic ryba is comparable with ruba''sun'' in Gweno(Tanzania) and dialectal Latvian zuve with zuva''sun'' in Shona(Zimbabwe,Mozambique). Slavic and Baltic are neighbour languages , Tanzania and Mozambique are neighbour too. Gweno and Shona are Bantu languages. I will not write about Bantu-Balti . I can't explain why. 
Referinţă Bibliografică:
SKY-SUN-EARTH THEORY.FISH / Ion Cârstoiu : Confluenţe Literare, ISSN 2359-7593, Ediţia nr. 2931, Anul IX, 09 ianuarie 2019.

Drepturi de Autor: Copyright © 2019 Ion Cârstoiu : Toate Drepturile Rezervate.
Utilizarea integrală sau parţială a articolului publicat este permisă numai cu acordul autorului.

Abonare la articolele scrise de Ion Cârstoiu
Like-urile, distribuirile și comentariile tale pe Facebook, Linkedin, Pinterest și Disqus se consideră gesturi prin care susții autorii îndrăgiți și promovezi creațiile valoroase din cuprinsul revistei. Îți mulțumim anticipat pentru această importantă contribuție la dezvoltarea publicației. Dacă doreşti să ne semnalezi anumite comentarii, te rugăm să ne scrii pe adresa de e-mail

Publicaţia Confluenţe Literare se bazează pe contribuţia prin postare directă a lucrărilor multor autori talentaţi din toate părţile lumii.

Sistemul de publicare este prin intermediul conturilor de autor, emise ca urmare a unei evaluări în urma trimiterii unui profil de autor împreună cu mai multe materiale de referinţă sau primirii unei recomandări din partea unui autor existent. Este obligatorie prezentarea identității solicitantului, chiar și în cazul publicării sub pseudonim. Conturile inactive pe o durată mai mare de un an vor fi suspendate, dar vor putea fi din nou activate la cerere.

Responsabilitatea asupra conţinutului articolelor aparţine în întregime autorilor, punctele de vedere sau opiniile expuse nefiind sub responsabilitatea administrației publicației. Răspunderea juridică asupra conținutului articolelor, inclusiv copyright-ul, aparține exclusiv autorului.

Sistemul de publicare fiind automat, administrația publicației nu este implicată în promovarea vreunui autor sau a scrierilor acestuia și nici în asumarea răspunderii editoriale sau de conținut. Dacă apar probleme de natură rasială, etnică sau copyright, vă rugăm să ni le semnalaţi pentru remediere prin ștergere la adresa de corespondenţă mai jos menţionată.

Articolele care vor fi contestate justificat prin e-mail vor fi retrase de pe site, mergându-se până la eliminarea completă a autorului care a încălcat principiile de copyright sau de non-discriminare.


Fondatori: George Roca și Octavian Lupu

Consultaţi Catalogul autorilor pentru o listă completă a autorilor.






Valid HTML 4.01 Transitional
CSS valid!